Golden Nugget Eye Pencil - EP11

The pigment is unreal for a pencil this cheap, and the tip stays sharp enough for a crisp wing without tugging. I drew a thin line at 7am and it was still there after the gym, no smudging under my eyes.

Wore this through a 12-hour shift and it didn't budge, even after a sweaty commute. The waterproof claim actually holds up, though it does take a decent oil cleanser to get off at night. Waterline stays sharp all day, which no other pencil has managed for me.

I've never had a pencil glide on this smoothly without tugging at my eyelid, and the waterproof claim actually holds up in the pool. The waterline definition lasted from morning until I washed my face at night.